Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Buffington's menu

18 dishes across 5 sections $10 to $20 American restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Buffington's photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Buffington's photo menu 1 Buffington's photo menu 2 Buffington's photo menu 3 Buffington's photo menu 4 Buffington's photo menu 5 Buffington's photo menu 6 Buffington's photo menu 7 Buffington's photo menu 8 Buffington's photo menu 9 Buffington's photo menu 10

Food - Appetizers 4 dishes

  • Large Fry Basket US$6.95

    Basket of seasoned crinkle cut fries

  • Small Fry Basket US$4.25

    Basket of seasoned crinkle cut fries

  • Large Fried Pickles US$6.95

    Dill chips, battered and golden fried with a side of ranch.

  • Small Fried Pickles US$4.25

    Dill chips, battered and golden fried with a side of ranch.

Food - Burgers & Chicken 10 dishes

  • Chicken Burger - Double

  • Chicken Burger - Single

    Marinated boneless chicken thigh, seasoned and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Impossible - Double

    Two patties made from Plants, tastes like meat, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Impossible - Jr

    A patty made from Plants, tastes like meat, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Smash Beef Patty - Double

    Two seasoned beef patties, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and buff's sauce.

  • Smash Beef Patty - Jr

    A seasoned beef patty, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and buff's sauce.

  • Tenders - 5 Piece

    5 hand breaded tenders with a side of Buff's sauce.

  • Tenders - 7 Piece

    7 Hand breaded tenders with a side of Buff sauce

  • Veggie Patty - Double

    Two veggie patties made with black beans, rice, and smoked mushrooms, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Veggie Patty - Jr

    Veggie patty made with black beans, rice, and smoked mushroom, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and buff's sauce.

Food - Grilled Sandwich 6 dishes

  • Patty Melt

    Beef smashed patty, American and provolone cheeses, and caramelized onions melted on thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread.

  • Grilled Chicken Melt

    Boneless, seared chicken thigh, provolone cheese, and pickled red onion. Melted on thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread.

  • Grilled Cheese

    American cheese, Cheddar Cheese, and Provolone Cheese stacked and melted between thick-cut white bread.

  • Fluffer Nutter

    Creamy Peanut Butter and Marshmallow Fluff on buttered and thick-cut white bread.

  • William Nelson

    Willie Nelson for short- Fried chicken tenders, bacon, ranch, BBQ sauce and American cheese. Melted on thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread.

  • Create Your Own

    Start with our thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread, and add what your heart desires.

Food - Soup & Salad & A La Carte 8 dishes

  • Soup And Salad US$7.95

    A side salad with Mixed greens, Roma tomato, cucumber, shredded cheese, and pickled red onion paired with a cup of your choice of Bob Marley, Chili or Seasonal soup* *When available,

  • Bob Marley Bowl

    Original from 1999, Bob Marley is a creamy soup with jerk chicken, rice, and roasted red peppers.

  • Bob Marley Cup US$4.25

    Original from 1999, Bob Marley is a creamy soup with jerk chicken, rice, and roasted red peppers.

  • Chili Bowl

    Our 3-bean chili sports black beans, red beans and pinto beans, fire roasted tomato, and chipotle peppers.

  • Chili Cup US$4.25

    Our 3-bean chili sports black beans, red beans and pinto beans, fire roasted tomato, and chipotle peppers.

  • Garden Salad US$6.95

    Mixed greens, Roma tomato, cucumber, shredded cheese, and pickled red onion. Add a protein of choice.

  • Side Salad US$4.15

    Mixed greens, Roma tomato, cucumber, shredded cheese, and pickled red onion.

  • Mac N Cheese Cup US$3.85

    Cup of Mac & Cheese topped with beer cheese.

Appetizers 4 dishes

  • Large Fry Basket US$6.95

    Basket of seasoned crinkle cut fries

  • Small Fry Basket US$4.25

    Basket of seasoned crinkle cut fries

  • Large Fried Pickles US$6.95

    Dill chips, battered and golden fried with a side of ranch.

  • Small Fried Pickles US$4.25

    Dill chips, battered and golden fried with a side of ranch.

Burgers & Chicken 10 dishes

  • Chicken Burger - Double

  • Chicken Burger - Single

    Marinated boneless chicken thigh, seasoned and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Impossible - Double

    Two patties made from Plants, tastes like meat, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Impossible - Jr

    A patty made from Plants, tastes like meat, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Smash Beef Patty - Double

    Two seasoned beef patties, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and buff's sauce.

  • Smash Beef Patty - Jr

    A seasoned beef patty, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and buff's sauce.

  • Tenders - 5 Piece

    5 hand breaded tenders with a side of Buff's sauce.

  • Tenders - 7 Piece

    7 Hand breaded tenders with a side of Buff sauce

  • Veggie Patty - Double

    Two veggie patties made with black beans, rice, and smoked mushrooms, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and Buff's sauce.

  • Veggie Patty - Jr

    Veggie patty made with black beans, rice, and smoked mushroom, smashed and seared. All burgers & sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle, and buff's sauce.

Grilled Sandwich 6 dishes

  • Patty Melt

    Beef smashed patty, American and provolone cheeses, and caramelized onions melted on thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread.

  • Grilled Chicken Melt

    Boneless, seared chicken thigh, provolone cheese, and pickled red onion. Melted on thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread.

  • Grilled Cheese

    American cheese, Cheddar Cheese, and Provolone Cheese stacked and melted between thick-cut white bread.

  • Fluffer Nutter

    Creamy Peanut Butter and Marshmallow Fluff on buttered and thick-cut white bread.

  • William Nelson

    Willie Nelson for short- Fried chicken tenders, bacon, ranch, BBQ sauce and American cheese. Melted on thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread.

  • Create Your Own

    Start with our thick-cut buttered and grilled white bread, and add what your heart desires.

Soup & Salad & A La Carte 8 dishes

  • Soup And Salad US$7.95

    A side salad with Mixed greens, Roma tomato, cucumber, shredded cheese, and pickled red onion paired with a cup of your choice of Bob Marley, Chili or Seasonal soup* *When available,

  • Bob Marley Bowl

    Original from 1999, Bob Marley is a creamy soup with jerk chicken, rice, and roasted red peppers.

  • Bob Marley Cup US$4.25

    Original from 1999, Bob Marley is a creamy soup with jerk chicken, rice, and roasted red peppers.

  • Chili Bowl

    Our 3-bean chili sports black beans, red beans and pinto beans, fire roasted tomato, and chipotle peppers.

  • Chili Cup US$4.25

    Our 3-bean chili sports black beans, red beans and pinto beans, fire roasted tomato, and chipotle peppers.

  • Garden Salad US$6.95

    Mixed greens, Roma tomato, cucumber, shredded cheese, and pickled red onion. Add a protein of choice.

  • Side Salad US$4.15

    Mixed greens, Roma tomato, cucumber, shredded cheese, and pickled red onion.

  • Mac N Cheese Cup US$3.85

    Cup of Mac & Cheese topped with beer cheese.

NA Bev - Soda 15 dishes

  • Coke US$3.00

  • Diet Coke US$3.00

  • Coke Zero US$3.00

  • Dr. Pepper US$3.00

  • Sprite US$3.00

  • Lemonade US$3.00

  • Shirley Temple US$3.50

  • Water US$0.00

  • Red Bull US$3.50

  • Sugar Free Red Bull US$3.50

  • Blue Red Bull US$3.50

  • Root Beer US$3.00

  • Mexican Coke US$3.50

  • Root Beer Bottle US$3.50

  • Fanta Orange US$3.50

NA Bev - Tea 3 dishes

  • Sweet Tea US$2.50

  • UnSweet Tea US$2.50

  • Arnold Palmer US$3.00

NA Bev - Float 3 dishes

  • Coke Float US$7.55

  • Root Beer Float US$7.55

  • Orange Crush Float US$7.55

Soda 15 dishes

  • Coke US$3.00

  • Diet Coke US$3.00

  • Coke Zero US$3.00

  • Dr. Pepper US$3.00

  • Sprite US$3.00

  • Lemonade US$3.00

  • Shirley Temple US$3.50

  • Water US$0.00

  • Red Bull US$3.50

  • Sugar Free Red Bull US$3.50

  • Blue Red Bull US$3.50

  • Root Beer US$3.00

  • Mexican Coke US$3.50

  • Root Beer Bottle US$3.50

  • Fanta Orange US$3.50

Tea 3 dishes

  • Sweet Tea US$2.50

  • UnSweet Tea US$2.50

  • Arnold Palmer US$3.00

Float 3 dishes

  • Coke Float US$7.55

  • Root Beer Float US$7.55

  • Orange Crush Float US$7.55

Add Ons - Extras 8 dishes

  • Ranch US$1.00

  • Blue Cheese US$1.00

  • Buff Sauce US$1.00

  • Balsamic US$1.00

  • Beer Cheese US$2.00

  • Honey Mustard US$1.00

  • Wing Sauce US$1.00

  • BBQ US$1.00

Extras 8 dishes

  • Ranch US$1.00

  • Blue Cheese US$1.00

  • Buff Sauce US$1.00

  • Balsamic US$1.00

  • Beer Cheese US$2.00

  • Honey Mustard US$1.00

  • Wing Sauce US$1.00

  • BBQ US$1.00

Test - Items 1 dishes

  • Bacon US$0.00

Items 1 dishes

  • Bacon US$0.00

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

I’m excited to introduce Buffington's, a laid-back American restaurant that locals genuinely enjoy for its easygoing charm and reliable comfort food, right in the heart of downtown Milledgeville. Located at 120 W Hancock St, Milledgeville, GA 31061, United States, Buffington's feels like one of those spots you can walk into without a plan and still have a great time. The vibe is casual and welcoming, which makes it a natural choice whether you’re meeting friends, grabbing something quick, or settling in for a relaxed evening. As an American restaurant, the menu focuses on familiar flavors done right, leaning into comfort food while still offering enough variety to keep things interesting. Drinks play a big role here, so you’ll find a solid mix of beer, wine, cocktails, and spirits, plus coffee for anyone easing into the day. Happy-hour drinks and happy-hour food add an extra layer of energy, especially when the place starts filling up with regulars and first-timers mingling easily. Late-night food is another highlight, making Buffington's a dependable option when other kitchens start closing. Service is flexible and fits modern needs, since you can choose dine-in for the full experience or go with takeaway, delivery, or no-contact delivery when convenience matters most. I also like that the menu considers different preferences, offering vegetarian and vegan options alongside small plates and quick bites that work well for sharing. Overall, Buffington's comes across as approachable and unpretentious, with a steady rhythm that suits casual meals, spontaneous plans, and those moments when you just want good food and drinks without any fuss.

Other menus in Milledgeville

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Milledgeville listings
Call Menu Directions